The following email was received, however a URL could not be found. As always, Aaron Lerner is insightful and instructive as to campaign priorities for defeating the Humpty-Dumpty Prime Minister. MB
—– Original Message —–
From: “Women in Green”
To:
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2005 2:24 PM
Subject: Framing Israel’s Elections As Retreat Referendum Could Defeat Sharon by Aaron Lerner
Weekly Commentary: Framing Israel’s Elections As Retreat Referendum
Could Defeat Sharon by Aaron Lerner
While Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s plans to carry out a major retreat in Judea and Samaria after the elections certainly appeal to the elements in the Left now supporting his “Kadima” Party, the Israeli public overwhelmingly rejects his scheme.
Turn the upcoming Knesset elections into a referendum on unilateral
withdrawal instead of a personality contest and Kadima will plummet.
That’s the challenge facing the national camp.
And it remains to be seen if the personalities running the campaigns of the national camp parties will realize that the retreat issue is their only solid hope to whittle down the support this essentially one-man party enjoys to what should be its natural size.
Play the corruption card? Polls show the public knows full well that
Sharonis corrupt but they don’t care.
Highlight commitment to social-welfare policy? Make this the defining
issue of the campaign and you are just another “me too”.
Remind voters about the lefties in Kadima? It may convince some voters to “come home” but Sharon is running as the man on the horse who does what he wants, when he wants to, and could give a damn what anyone else says (or for that matter what he himself may have said before), so the composition of his party is of secondary importance.
Israel loves this ultimate man on the horse.
But Israel doesn’t want the retreat Sharon is planning.
A poll of a representative sample of 500 adult Israeli Jews carried out by Smith Research & Consulting on 29-30 November and sponsored by ZOA – The Zionist Organization of America – finds that 67% oppose carrying out a significant unilateral withdrawal from Judea and Samaria if it is not possible to advance in negotiations with the Palestinians on the basis of the Road Map after the elections because the PA fails to fight terror.
Among those who indicated that they plan to vote for Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s Kadima Party, 54% oppose and 37% support carrying out a significant unilateral withdrawal under those circumstances.
And the public sees retreat as a defining issue.
A follow up question found that of those who oppose unilateral withdrawal under those circumstances, 75% responded that they would not vote for a party that would support such a move.
Hammer the message home that a vote for Sharon is a vote for retreat and there is nothing he can say that will convince voters that this isn’t the case.
Ironically, the very thing that appeals to Israelis: that he does what he wants, when he wants to, and could give a damn what anyone else says or what he himself may have said before – would then be his Achilles heel.